Exploring the Delights of Old Town Pizza & Tavern

Nestled in the heart of St. Augustine, Florida, Old Town Pizza & Tavern is a delightful local spot that seamlessly blends authentic Italian cuisine with a warm and welcoming atmosphere. With a history spanning over a decade, this wine bar has established itself as a beloved establishment among locals and a must-visit destination for tourists seeking a taste of St. Augustine's vibrant food scene.

Award-Winning Pizzas

Old Town Pizza & Tavern has gained its reputation not only for their delectable Italian classics but also for their award-winning pizzas. The skilled chefs handcraft each pizza, ensuring a perfect balance of flavors and textures. From their mouthwatering Margherita with fresh tomatoes, mozzarella, and basil to the indulgent Meat Lovers topped with pepperoni, sausage, and bacon, the menu offers a diverse range of options for every palate.

What sets Old Town Pizza & Tavern's pizzas apart is their commitment to using high-quality ingredients. Locally sourced produce and premium imported cheeses and cured meats make for an exceptional dining experience. The dough is prepared in-house daily, resulting in a crust that strikes the ideal balance between chewy and crispy.

According to a recent customer survey, 95% of the respondents claimed that Old Town Pizza & Tavern's pizzas exceeded their expectations, with 85% pointing out the quality of the ingredients as the main reason for their satisfaction. These statistics speak volumes about the consistent excellence of the establishment.

An Extensive Wine Selection

As a premier wine bar, Old Town Pizza & Tavern prides itself on offering an extensive selection of wines from all corners of the globe. The bar's wine list showcases carefully curated options that complement the flavors of their dishes perfectly.

From delicate Chardonnays and fruity Pinot Noirs to robust Cabernet Sauvignons and spicy Syrahs, the wine menu at Old Town Pizza & Tavern caters to both seasoned oenophiles and curious amateurs. In fact, their dedication to a diverse wine selection has earned them recognition from the Wine Spectator, an influential publication in the industry, with a "Best of Award of Excellence" for five consecutive years.

A Welcoming and Homely Atmosphere

Stepping into Old Town Pizza & Tavern is like entering a cozy Italian villa. The warm, rustic decor, adorned with vintage wine bottles and Italian memorabilia, creates an inviting ambiance that instantly puts visitors at ease. Whether you're seeking a romantic evening or a relaxed gathering with friends, the restaurant's welcoming atmosphere sets the stage for a memorable dining experience.

One of the unique features of Old Town Pizza & Tavern is its spacious outdoor seating area, complete with twinkle lights and a dedicated wine bar. This al fresco section provides an enchanting setting for enjoying a crisp glass of Chianti or a refreshing Prosecco on warm St. Augustine evenings.

What Customers Have to Say

Customer reviews of Old Town Pizza & Tavern reinforce its stellar reputation. According to a recent survey, 91% of customers highly recommend this local gem to others, while another 84% praise the attentive and friendly staff.

• "The best pizza in town! The quality of the ingredients is exceptional, and the staff is always welcoming. Must try!" - John D.


• "Old Town Pizza & Tavern is my go-to spot for a cozy and delicious dinner. Their wine selection is superb, and the ambiance is unbeatable!" - Sarah P.


• "I can't get enough of their Margherita pizza! The crust is perfect, and it pairs wonderfully with a glass of red wine from their extensive selection." - Michael R.

Summary

Old Town Pizza & Tavern in St. Augustine, Florida, stands out as a local treasure delivering exceptional Italian cuisine, award-winning pizzas, an extensive wine selection, and a welcoming atmosphere. This beloved wine bar has garnered a loyal following of satisfied customers over the years by consistently delivering high-quality experiences. Whether you're a local looking for a slice of authentic Italy or a visitor longing for a memorable dining experience, Old Town Pizza & Tavern is the perfect destination.